The Sweet Tooth & Catering Menu
The Sweet Tooth & Catering is a Brooklyn gem known for soulful, pork-free dishes and exceptional baked goods, all crafted with heartfelt passion. Located on Marcus Garvey Blvd, this Black-owned establishment has thrived for 17 years by staying true to its roots. Their menu shines with standout items like the crispy shrimp and flounder Po'boy sandwiches, layered with secret sauces and fresh slaw, delivering a perfect crunch and savory depth.
The catering menu impresses with vibrant salads—mesclun, pasta, and potato—paired with flavorful hot appetizers such as codfish croquettes and tender turkey meatballs, which guests rave about. Desserts, however, steal the spotlight. From moist, nostalgic cakes like banana pudding, key lime cheesecake, and the legendary lemon cake, to the rich sweet potato cheesecake, each bite captures a blend of tradition and finesse.
Owner Shakoor’s dedication is evident in every dish and interaction, making The Sweet Tooth & Catering not just a meal, but an experience of warmth, authenticity, and culinary excellence.